Vehicle Accident Review Policy

Policy number: 2014-05

Effective date: June 9, 2014

Last revision date: June 9, 2014


On this page

  1. Purpose
  2. Definitions
  3. Defensive Driving Mission Statement
  4. Policy
  5. References
  6. Schedules

1. Purpose

To ensure that operators of County vehicles and equipment, at all times, act in accordance with County standards, training programs, legislative requirements and in the interest of their own and the public’s safety including the avoidance of property damage.

To form a Vehicle Accident Review Committee to inquire into the circumstances, causes, results and prevention of all vehicle and equipment accidents. The committee is to report its findings on the Vehicle Accident Review Committee Form (Schedule “A” - attached) and where appropriate, make recommendations to prevent the reoccurrence of similar accidents.

To ensure that corrective action is taken to eliminate accidents caused by driver error and to satisfy Haldimand County’s legislated obligations under the Ontario Highway Traffic Act and CVOR legislation.


2. Definitions

"CVOR": means Commercial Vehicle Operators Registration.

"Driver/Operator": means County employees, including volunteer firefighters that drive or operate County vehicles and equipment.

"HTA": means Ontario Highway Traffic Act.

"VARC": means Vehicle Accident Review Committee.

"Vehicle and Equipment": means County owned and managed vehicles and equipment which have been classified as follows:

    1. Commercial Motor Vehicles – licensed vehicles with a RGVW rating over 4,500 kg. (approximately 10,000 lbs.) and buses or vans, operated on a highway for the purpose of transporting disabled persons. The vehicle’s gross weight rating is shown on the ownership papers. Commercial vehicles are subject to commercial vehicle CVOR legislation. Although considered commercial motor vehicles, fire apparatus, ambulances and vehicles to transport the disabled are exempt from CVOR legislation.
    2. Light Duty Vehicles – licensed vehicles with a RGVW rating of 4,500 kg. or less include light pick-up trucks, vans and automobiles.  These  vehicles are exempt from CVOR legislation.
    3. Off Road Vehicles - non-licensed vehicles and/or equipment such as street sweepers, loaders, graders, tractors, etc., used for construction work.
    4. Equipment - handheld or stationary equipment such as chainsaws, trimmers, push mowers, pumps, generators, etc. or self propelled equipment such as ride-on mowers, garden tractors, ice maintenance equipment, etc.

3. Defensive Driving Mission Statement

Haldimand County drivers are expected to drive defensively at all times. Defensive driving is driving to avoid accidents in spite of the incorrect actions of others and adverse conditions. Defensive drivers must also compensate for adverse weather conditions, road, traffic and vehicle conditions, and avoid any emotional disturbances which may distract their attention from driving. Defensive drivers must not let the actions of others disturb them, and must ensure their actions do not disturb other users of the road or pedestrians.


4. Policy

Haldimand County has a legal and moral responsibility to ensure that County owned vehicles and equipment are operated in a safe efficient manner and that all vehicular accidents are reported and dealt with in a timely manner. All reasonable precautions will be taken to prevent accidents arising from the operation of vehicles and equipment which may cause damage to property, and/or injury or death to County employees, other drivers or pedestrians.

This Vehicle Accident Review Policy applies to all operators of County vehicles and equipment. If an operator of Haldimand County vehicles or equipment is involved in an accident, their Non-Union Supervisor must be notified immediately. A Vehicle Accident/Incident Report must be submitted to the Fleet  and Equipment Operations Division in accordance with the Haldimand County Corporate Fleet Policy.

All Supervisors, in consultation with their Division Manager, must investigate any accidents in accordance with the guidelines set out in the Vehicle Accident/Incident Report and assist the Fleet Coordinator of Safety/Training and/or the Vehicle Accident Review Committee (VARC) with any follow-up investigation.

The Vehicle Accident/Incident Report is to be completed even if the County will incur no costs for the repair. This will provide for efficient tracking and record keeping of incidents that have occurred with Haldimand County vehicles.

This policy is to be used in conjunction with the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act, Ontario Highway Traffic Act (HTA) and any relevant Haldimand County Health and Safety Policies or Procedures.

Any personal injuries arising from a vehicle or equipment accident must be reported in accordance with the current Human Resources Division policies and procedures.

All vehicle/equipment accident reports will be submitted to the Vehicle Accident Review Committee to review and classify as preventable or non-preventable, in accordance with Schedule “B” – Preventable / Non Preventable Accidents Guidelines (as attached).

For the purpose of counselling,  determining  the re-training  or the administration of discipline, reported accidents will be divided into three categories. The categories are as follows:

  • Preventable Accident - Defined as an accident, where after an investigation, it is determined that the operator was a contributing factor to the cause of the accident.
  • Non Preventable Accident - Defined as an accident where after an investigation it is determined that the operator was not a contributing factor to the cause of the accident.
  • Damage Report - Defined as an accident/incident resulting in physical damage to the vehicle/equipment, where no bodily injury occurred, and where after the supervisors investigation, it is determined that there was no contributing factor on the part of the operator.

Revisions and amendments to this policy will be issued from time to time, in accordance with Schedule “B” – Preventable / Non-Preventable Accidents Guidelines and the Highway Traffic Act.

Vehicle Accident Review Committee

Members:

    • Health and Safety Coordinator
    • Fleet Coordinator of Safety/Training
    • Coordinator Risk Management
    • Manager of Fleet and Equipment Operations (advisor when required)
    • Manager or designate of the affected Division (as a resource when required)

Frequencies of Meetings

Meetings will be held monthly following the Joint Health and Safety Committee meeting. Special meetings may be called if necessary.

Duties of the Committee

    • Review and establish the accuracy and thoroughness of the statements contained in the original accident report.
    • Recommend actions for the prevention of similar future accidents.
    • Categorize the accident as preventable or non-preventable.
    • Document findings on the Vehicle Accident Review Committee Form.
    • Identify and establish accident trends.
    • Report to the applicable General Manager in the event there are any differences in findings between the Committee and the decision of the applicable Manager.
    • Prepare an annual report to be submitted to the Senior Management Team (SMT) for their review.

Distribution of Committee Reports

Copies of the report will be marked “CONFIDENTIAL” and distributed to:

    • Division Manager (copy to be forwarded to the employee)
    • Non-Union Supervisor of the employee.
    • Driver’s file (Fleet Coordinator of Safety/Training).

Vehicle/Equipment Accident Corrective Action

This policy is intended to ensure that corrective action is being taken to eliminate accidents caused by driver error.

It is the responsibility of the employee’s Division Manager and Non-Union Supervisor, in consultation with the Human Resources Division, to ensure that any discipline and/or retraining requirements are administered.

If the accident is deemed preventable  (as per Schedule “B” – Preventable / Non- Preventable Accident  Guidelines),  progressive  discipline  may be used to address performance concerns of the driver involved. Unless unique circumstances warrant and/or depending on the seriousness of the accident, the following progressive disciplinary steps will be used:

    1. Verbal discussion to set performance expectations, confirmed in writing.
    2. Verbal reprimand, confirmed in writing (minimum step for preventable CVOR events that affect the County’s CVOR rating).
    3. Written reprimand.
    4. Suspension.
    5. Termination depending on incident, General Manager recommendation and Chief Administrative Officer approval.

Non CVOR Vehicles/Equipment

Step 1 - First preventable incident
Step 2 - Second preventable incident within an eighteen (18) month period
Step 3 - Third preventable incident within an eighteen (18) month period
Step 4 - Fourth preventable incident within an eighteen (18) month period

CVOR Vehicles

Step 2 - First preventable incident
Step 3 - Second preventable incident within an eighteen (18) month period
Step 4 - Third preventable incident within in eighteen (18) month period

Retraining will be required as directed by the Manager, Fleet and Equipment Operations Division.

Supervisors shall consult with the applicable Manager, General Manager and the Manager of Human Resources when considering disciplinary action. A recommendation to either suspend or terminate requires  the approval of the Chief  Administrative  Officer,  or designate.

Any disciplinary action shall be documented and provided to the employee, with a copy forwarded to the applicable General Manager and the Human Resources Division for placement in the employee’s personnel file. The employee shall have the opportunity to respond, in writing, to any disciplinary action and request that a copy of the submitted document be placed in his/her personnel file. After eighteen months, if there are no related incidents, the employee may request removal of the disciplinary record(s). Continued employment with Haldimand County shall be conditional upon satisfactory performance at any time.

NOTE:

  1. An employee who fails to report a vehicle accident shall be subject to disciplinary action up to and including the possible suspension of his/her operating privileges or dismissal.
  2. An employee who is involved in a vehicle accident and is found to be under the influence of alcohol, drugs or other intoxicants will be subject to disciplinary action up to and including dismissal.

5. References

  • Fleet Safety Council (Infrastructure Health and Safety Association)
  • Canada Safety Council
  • Ontario Highway Traffic Act
  • Occupational Health and Safety Act

Schedules

To request an available attachment, please contact the Clerks Division.

                Available attachment(s):

1. Vehicle Accident Review Form
2. Preventable/Non-Preventable Accidents Guidelines

Contact Us

Haldimand County
53 Thorburn Street South
Cayuga, Ontario
Canada, N0A 1E0

Phone: 905-318-5932

After hours (Road, Sewer, Water or Park & Public Facilities Emergencies): 1-888-849-7345